It’s not unusual during the weeks leading up to Thanksgiving in the United States for churches to create sermon series around the topic of gratitude or thankfulness. But this year our Thursday gatherings at Harbor have been focused on finding hope in community. This past week, co-pastor Jon Mathieu led a study on the difference between optimism and hope. Reading back over the slides from his presentation he offers a loose definition of hope. He suggests that it’s a deep-seated sense of agency, determination, meaning, and goodness during bad circumstances, even if the circumstances do not improve.
I came to Harbor in September 2022, and in the four years I’ve been part of this community I don’t think there’s ever been a more accurate definition of the hope I’ve found here. The word that stands out most to me in Jon’s definition is agency.
For most of my first year here, I struggled with feelings of failure because I didn’t attend every meeting or event. It was a shame that I carried with me from my former life in the evangelical community, where the depth of a person’s faithfulness was often measured by their attendance record. One day during a call with our former co-pastor Dottie, she asked me why I felt the need to apologize for the times I wasn’t present. She told me that my value to Harbor was not based on how often I attended, how much I volunteered, or what I could do for the community. I was valued because I existed. It didn’t matter whether I could only join in once every two months or multiple times a week—I wasn’t any less a part of the community.
I was missed but not judged, and hearing a pastor say that to me did more to heal my broken perspective of agency that she probably realized.
Not all bad circumstances improve over time—some things just are. Permanent disability, chronic illness, mental illness … these things don’t always get better. I think it’s a danger to a person’s faith and their connectedness to others to expect someone living with any of those things to show up with a permanent smile on their faces and an unhealthy optimism that they can perform or pray their pain away. A safe and healthy community is a place where agency is encouraged.
I find hope at Harbor because it is a community of people who don’t try to minimize or dismiss my circumstances. They don’t measure my faith by my lack of attendance or limitations. My humanity is honored in full as part of experiencing this world as God created it. More than that, my perspective is welcomed.
It is a wonderful experience to be part of a community that doesn’t just tell you to look for the silver lining or to be grateful for what you do have, but where the people within it become those things. They embody the determination, meaning, and goodness that strengthens hope. And what comes from experiencing a hope like this is expression. It is easier to express love for another when you have experienced it for yourself. It is easier to care for another when you are cared for.
I’ve been asked more than a few times how Harbor builds community as an online church. As someone who once thought of community as the group of people I spent the most time with, I know how hard it can be to challenge that framework. But what I’ve come to realize and find so healing is that community is actually the group of people with whom I experience the most hope. No matter what we are facing personally or as a collective, we are determined to accept and encourage one another—which anchors us so that we can go out into our respective lives and do the same for others.
I can’t think of a better way to build community.